This post contains affiliate links for which I could earn commission if you clickand buy.
Both Le Creuset and the Lodge have their own fan club. The discussion can get heated because each party has its own opinion about which brand produces the best Dutch stove. We are not here to decide for you, but we will help you highlight the differences in the debates between Le Creuset and Lodge. There are similarities and differences, especially in the details. One does not necessarily have to cost more than the other. It all depends on individual preferences, right down to the colour of the cookware, which can tip the balance in favour of the purchase. So it is not right or wrong for you to decide to spend money on Le Creuset or keep it for Lodge. Both have their pros and cons, which you have to think about.
What are we comparing?
==> Cheque price
Lodge is known for its cast iron crockery, while Le Creuset Signature is often described as one of the best Dutch stoves on the market. So we compare their Dutch enamelled cast iron ovens. Then the next question arises: What are glazed dishes?
Basically, enamelled dishes have an extra layer cast on metal, in this case cast iron. This layer is a glass mould called porcelain enamel, which is attached to the cast iron by means of extremely high temperatures. The result is a smooth cooking surface, as can often be seen on enamelled pots and pans.
There are several reasons to choose an enamelled stove instead of a cast iron stove made in the Netherlands. The extra layer provides a smoother, easier to clean surface and the lighter colour gives a better appearance. It is also easier to follow the cooking process with a lighter surface, especially for baking food. The enamel layer also prevents changes in the taste of food, because it does not contain bare metal and does not react to acidic or alkaline foods.
Probably the strongest motivation for enamelled cast iron tableware is the fact that, unlike cast iron tableware, it does not require much care. You don’t have to worry about spices and baking to keep a piece. No wonder many people are willing to pay more for a Dutch enamelled cast iron stove than for a bald one.
Le Creuset vs. Lodge – differences
==> Check price
This is probably the most obvious difference between Le Creuset and Lodge. Price is also something most people look at first when evaluating two options, especially if they have to work within budget. And the price difference here is huge. A Le Creuset Signature Dutch oven costs about 6 to 7 times more than a container of comparable size.
Some people think the high price just isn’t worth it. Others believe that better quality justifies a high price. Some of the differences between the two brands are responsible for the huge price difference, but whether you have to pay so much more for Le Creuset depends on the value you assign to each item.
Place of manufacture
Lodge is known for its prepared meals in America. But the enamelled stove from Dutch Lodge is the place where customers often make the wrong choice. This happened in China, not in the United States. Some customers really feel cheated when they only realize that they are being imported after they have received their order.
The Dutch oven Le Creuset, on the other hand, is produced in France. Between the French and Chinese dishes we can already guess which one will be much more expensive. If you don’t mind marking Made in China, the wigwam will serve you well. But for those for whom the health and safety aspects are more important, they do not mind paying much more for goods produced here in Europe. If that’s the case, dust against Le Creuset is the next bone of contention!
Le Creuset’s Dutch stoves will have a more complete range of dimensions than the pavilion. If you need a very large Dutch oven to cook for 10 or more people, Le Creuset has the size you need, 9 and 13.25 pints. For Lodge, the largest capacity in the Netherlands is only 7.5 blocks, which can accommodate 7 to 8 people. Le Creuset’s largest Dutch oven is oval in shape and weighs 15.5 litres.
For some people the appearance is not that important, but for others a more beautiful colour can be the last factor that makes them choose a colour. Dutch Lodge’s enamelled cast iron stoves tend to be darker in colour. On the other hand, Le Creuset has a wide range of colours, some of which offer a lighter feel with lighter, happier shades.
The Dutch Ofenloge has a curved shape that runs downwards, while Le Creuset has a straighter side that connects to the ground at a steeper angle. Does the shape really matter? Well, we think that’s a bit important, because Le Creuset, with its right side wall, offers a bit more base than the Lodge, which tapers. This means you have more space to bake and search with Le Creuset.
However, the difference in size of the base is not so great that it would be a great inconvenience for Lodge. The 6-quarter lodge has a cooking area that is 10-15% less than that of the 5.5-quarter lodge Le Creuset. In this way, the pavilion can get a bit busier, but you can also decorate your kitchen and if necessary look for meat in batches.
But a curved construction also has its advantages. With a convex pot, pieces of food are easier to reach than with a sharp angle. This means that food is less likely to get stuck in a corner during baking.
The Le Creuset signature has a flatter binding than the log, which has a higher domed binding. There are good and bad role models for both. If you have little vertical space in your cupboard or oven, a shorter pan and a flatter lid may be suitable. However, if you are cooking a large amount of food or a whole chicken just above the edge of the pot, the dome-shaped lid is more convenient because your food will not be crushed when the lid is closed.
As for the bottom of the envelope, both are smooth. There are no peaks such as dust or condensation rings visible on the Martha Stewart Hollands stove.
Just like the Dutch Tramontina oven, the Lodge is equipped with a stainless steel handle for the lid and can house ovens up to 500°F. The Creuset models are mainly equipped with a combi lid handle, which is also safe for ovens up to 500°F, but some users are concerned about whether it can withstand such high oven temperatures. It is possible to purchase a stainless steel ballpoint pen separately, but this also means that you will have to pay about 20 dollars more for a replacement ballpoint pen.
Pens are important for the Dutch oven because it is a heavy piece of crockery. It should therefore be easy and safe to attach the handles, even with a glove. Both Lodge and Le Creuset have large handles that you can reach with your fingers. But Le Creuset has bigger pens because the noose is bigger. Le Creuset oven gloves make it easy to check when you take them out of the oven.
The quality of the finishing is better at Le Creuset than at the Lodge. It is smoother, while Lodge tends to have a more uneven finish. Lodge is also more inclined to leave footprints, and you can simply use a metal spoon with a few quick movements to make the footprints appear. Le Creuset is better because of the high quality finish with less risk of stirring marks on a light hob.
Compared to Lodge, we also hear less about cracks and chips in the glaze of the crucible. Although both should take a long time if properly cared for, the box of both is a little more fragile.
A comparison between Le Creuset and the Lodge would not have been complete if their culinary qualities had not also been discussed. In fact, there is no difference between the culinary characteristics of the two brands. Lodge can cook in the same way as Le Creuset, even with tanning and a fragrant stew. The food remains juicy and moist when the lid is tightly closed. If you are not a very skilled cook who demands the best, we think the lodge is enough to prepare a delicious meal.
What to buy?
As mentioned before, there is no right or wrong answer to this question, but the value you attach to the various functions will help you find a solution. Productivity and cooking results will not differ much for local chefs, but a brand is important to build confidence in safety, quality and sustainability. That’s what you’d pay for the French Crucible.
Are there special offers for Dutch stoves? Discover now:
Of course price would also be an important factor, and many buyers use it to solve Le Creuset vs. If you’re not sure, there’s nothing wrong with trying a more affordable option. If you can live without the best food for your kitchen, Lodge is the perfect alternative to part of the price of Le Creuset.
le creuset dutch oven,lodge enamel dutch oven,staub dutch oven,staub vs le creuset reddit,cocotte vs dutch oven,lodge enamel dutch oven 7.5 quart,bruntmor vs le creuset,le creuset vs staub
Disclosure: We are a professional review company & our reviews are not biased towards any of the products we review. We test each product thoroughly and give marks to only the very best that is given by our author. We are very independently owned & the opinions expressed here are our own. However, if you purchase anything after clicking the links present in the articles then we get some commissions for it which help maintaining the websites expenses like servers, security etc.